Early-career researchers (ECRs) are central to scientific progress, yet they remain underrepresented among peer reviewers and may not always receive credit for their contributions. A large-scale analysis of Nature Portfolio’s Early Career Researcher Co-Review program suggests that structured collaboration between established and early-career reviewers can increase ECR participation, narrow the gender gap among reviewers and improve transparency, while also revealing that broader international representation is still needed.
Expanding opportunities for early-career reviewers
Senior researchers bring broad knowledge and experience, but ECRs are often closer to the latest experimental methods, data-analysis techniques and rapidly changing technologies. Giving them a role in peer review allows them to help shape the scientific record while gaining experience in evaluating the work of their peers.
At the beginning of 2025, Nature joined the Nature Portfolio Early Career Researcher Collaborative Review Program. The initiative invites established reviewers to involve ECRs in the review process while retaining responsibility for the final report. Journal editors provide training to participating ECRs, who may later have opportunities to review research themselves.
Participation and representation
Nature Portfolio’s analysis found that the program increased ECR representation among reviewers and helped reduce the gender gap.
Overall, ECRs accounted for 17% of reviewers at Nature and 11% at Nature Communications. The analysis covered 78,661 reviewers and 24,645 research manuscripts submitted to Nature Communications between April 1, 2024, and July 31, 2025, and to Nature between February 1, 2025, and July 31, 2025.
The Nature Project is working to encourage peer review by young researchers.
More than a quarter of the manuscripts at both journals had at least one reviewer who was a PhD candidate or postdoctoral researcher. Women accounted for approximately 40% of ECR reviewers, compared with 24% of established reviewers.
In surveys of approximately 2,500 established researchers and 2,400 ECRs who took part in the collaborative review program, 88% of established researchers said they would be more likely to accept an invitation to review a paper if they could do so with an ECR. Almost all ECR respondents rated the initiative as an “excellent” or “good” way to involve early-career researchers and improve transparency in peer review. Many respondents also believed that ECR participation could reduce review times.
Geographic gaps remain
Despite these encouraging results, the analysis identified areas requiring further progress, including the involvement of a broader range of countries. Researchers affiliated with the United States made up the largest proportion of ECR reviewers at both journals. They accounted for 49% of reviewers at Nature, while most of the remaining reviewers also came from high-income countries.
Other routes into peer review
Nature Portfolio is not alone in creating structured pathways for ECRs to become reviewers. Several other publishers have introduced programs combining instruction, training and formal recognition.
For the past 15 years, EMBO Press journals including The EMBO Journal and EMBO Reports have encouraged established researchers to co-review papers with postdoctoral researchers in their laboratories, while requiring that co-reviewers receive recognition. In 2024, EMBO Press, which is operated by the European Molecular Biology Organization (EMBO), began inviting ECRs with at least two years of postdoctoral experience to participate directly in peer review. A representative said the publisher is monitoring the program’s uptake. Nature reported that the quality of ECR review reports is consistent with that of reviews completed by established reviewers.
Young researchers are losing out due to peer review ghostwriting.
In September, FEBS Open Bio, published by Wiley on behalf of the Federation of European Biochemical Societies, launched the Early Career Reviewer Hub. The initiative is designed to help PhD students and postdoctoral researchers gain peer-review experience in the molecular sciences. Participants receive training from journal editors and must nominate an established researcher as a mentor. They review papers describing research protocols and experimental procedures.
These programs indicate that the publishing community is taking further steps to involve ECRs in peer review.
Peer review is a foundation of research, providing a rigorous way to evaluate scientific work. It also teaches researchers how to assess their colleagues’ studies and gives them insight into how their own work will be evaluated.
However, the current system is under increasing pressure as scientists spend more time performing reviews. Publishers need to ensure that more ECRs can contribute to this essential service and receive recognition for their work. The reviewer community should also reflect the full diversity of the research it evaluates.
Source: www.nature.com











