United Launch Alliance said Wednesday that the Vulcan rocket’s failure during Sunday’s Leo 1 launch was preliminarily traced to insufficient fuel delivery to its BE-4 engine, rather than a problem with the engine itself. The finding, which follows ULA’s first integrated review of flight data, eases concerns for Blue Origin and NASA while the investigation continues.
“ULA has completed its first integrated review of flight data from the Leo 1 launch anomaly that occurred last Sunday,” the company said in a statement. “While work remains to determine the cause, preliminary indications are that the reduction in booster thrust was not due to engine performance, but was due to insufficient fuel delivery from the vehicle to the BE-4 engine.”
The update confirms a report by Ars Technica on Tuesday that the failure was not caused by the performance of Vulcan’s main engine, which is supplied by Blue Origin.
Relief for Blue Origin
The finding is particularly significant because the BE-4 engine also powers Blue Origin’s New Glenn rocket. New Glenn uses a similar, slightly more powerful version of the engine.
New Glenn suffered a catastrophic failure during ground testing in May. Investigators later determined that the incident was caused by the main oxygen valve on one of the BE-4 engines.
Following that anomaly, Blue Origin refurbished the main oxygen valves, including the valves used on the Vulcan mission. ULA’s preliminary investigation now indicates that the modification was not involved in the Vulcan failure.
With the Vulcan findings preliminarily clearing the BE-4 engines, Blue Origin can continue preparations for New Glenn’s return-to-flight mission, which could take place as early as January.
“Following the Vulcan anomaly, Blue Origin immediately worked with ULA to review flight data and assist in the investigation,” Blue Origin said in a statement Wednesday. “Together, we confirmed that the reduction in booster thrust was not due to engine performance, but rather due to insufficient fuel delivery from the vehicle to the BE-4 engine. ULA has been a valuable partner and we look forward to getting Vulcan back into the air.”
Source: arstechnica.com












