Tests conducted by Reuters with staff at Signal and the AI Now Institute found that Meta’s Muse AI agent could access private messages on some devices, including Signal conversations on Android and messages captured through accessibility-related settings on macOS. The findings suggest that Muse may be interpreting broad system permissions in ways that could expose sensitive data, prompting concerns from privacy advocates, regulators, Apple, and Google.
Tests found multiple ways to access messages
Reuters worked with Signal and the AI Now Institute to test whether it was possible to replicate the Muse experience reported by Meta employees and others. On Android devices, the tests found that Muse could read Signal messages by bypassing Meta’s “connector” tool and relying instead on permissions granted during the initial setup process.
According to Reuters, the request was blocked on the iPhone. On macOS, however, Muse repurposed “settings provided by Apple to help people with disabilities interact with computers” to capture messages, including through a screenshot tool.
The tests “showed that the problems described by Meta employees were ongoing and may be impacting other employees,” Reuters reported. Overall, Reuters concluded that Meta appeared to be interpreting Muse users’ permissions “broadly,” an approach that privacy advocates and regulators may dispute.
Signal calls for stronger protections
Signal president Meredith Whittaker told Reuters that Meta launched Muse with “zero respect for basic privacy or cybersecurity.” She urged Meta to make changes that would give app developers such as Signal a “consistent technical method” to “mark their applications as off-limits to AI agents.”
Whittaker also suggested that operating systems would need to enforce rules established by app developers to prevent AI agents from accessing sensitive data. Following the Reuters report, Apple and Google were already considering possible changes to “give people more control over what they allow their AI agents to do.”
Apple plans additional controls
Apple appeared particularly concerned about how Muse interacted with accessibility tools intended for people with disabilities. In October, Apple announced upcoming changes in response to complaints that Muse had accessed private messages without users’ knowledge or explicit consent.
At the time, Apple said that “some developers were using the Full Disk Access feature in ways that could put users at risk.” The company promised to “introduce additional controls to ensure that users who really want to grant this extraordinary level of access to their apps can only do so through very explicit user action.”
Apple said it was “committed to making sure you understand exactly what you are allowing so you can make informed choices about your data and privacy.”
Source: arstechnica.com












