Mondo News
    What's Hot
    All

    Jack Ma’s Alibaba among hundreds of Chinese firms facing delisting

    All

    Chinese researchers claim they have AI capable of reading minds

    All

    Endangered condors trash home of California mom

    • About Us
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Mondo News
    • Home
    • Technology

      NASA’s Grand Retirement Plan: Seeking Deorbit Craft for Space Station’s Safe Descent

      September 23, 2023

      First ever AI-written poetry anthology is bleak and alarming: ‘I have the power to end your world’

      September 23, 2023

      Andrew Yang on why we should be scared about the 2024 election: ‘Really destructive’

      September 23, 2023

      The evidence grows that ultra-processed foods play a role in depression

      September 23, 2023

      TV Networks’ Last Best Hope: Boomers

      September 23, 2023
    • Science

      Hybrid electric vehicles might not be the green machines consumers think they are

      September 23, 2023

      A Superconductivity Theory To Explain Reported LK99 Assuming Reports Were Correct

      September 23, 2023

      Hypertelescopes on the Moon Can Have Better than 1 Microarcsecond Resolution

      September 23, 2023

      In Hospitals, Viruses Are Everywhere. Masks Are Not.

      September 23, 2023

      Richard Branson has an urgent message for climate change deniers

      September 23, 2023
    • Blockchain

      SBF’s mom told him to ‘avoid’ disclosing millions in FTX donations to her pro-Dem PAC: suit

      September 22, 2023

      The Lawyers Sam Bankman-Fried Once Trusted Are Drawing Criticism

      September 21, 2023

      Imaging Surface of Exoplanets With 25 Kilometer Moon Crater Hypertelescopes

      September 21, 2023

      The Animals Are Talking. What Does It Mean?

      September 20, 2023

      Sponsor an ocean? Tiny island nation of Niue has a novel plan to protect its slice of the Pacific

      September 20, 2023
    • All

      Hybrid electric vehicles might not be the green machines consumers think they are

      September 23, 2023

      A Superconductivity Theory To Explain Reported LK99 Assuming Reports Were Correct

      September 23, 2023

      Hypertelescopes on the Moon Can Have Better than 1 Microarcsecond Resolution

      September 23, 2023

      NASA’s Grand Retirement Plan: Seeking Deorbit Craft for Space Station’s Safe Descent

      September 23, 2023

      First ever AI-written poetry anthology is bleak and alarming: ‘I have the power to end your world’

      September 23, 2023
    Mondo News
    You are at:Home»All»Three Feet or Six? Distancing Guideline for Schools Stirs Debate
    All March 17, 2021

    Three Feet or Six? Distancing Guideline for Schools Stirs Debate

    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Some public health officials say it’s time for the C.D.C. to loosen its social distancing guidelines for classrooms, but the idea has detractors.

    The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is clear and consistent in its social distancing recommendation: To reduce the risk of contracting the coronavirus, people should remain at least six feet away from others who are not in their households. The guideline holds whether you are eating in a restaurant, lifting weights at a gym or learning long division in a fourth-grade classroom.

    The guideline has been especially consequential for schools, many of which have not fully reopened because they do not have enough space to keep students six feet apart.

    Now, spurred by a better understanding of how the virus spreads and a growing concern about the harms of keeping children out of school, some public health experts are calling on the agency to reduce the recommended distance in schools from six feet to three.

    “It never struck me that six feet was particularly sensical in the context of mitigation,” said Dr. Ashish Jha, dean of the Brown University School of Public Health. “I wish the C.D.C. would just come out and say this is not a major issue.”

    The idea remains contentious, in part because few studies have directly compared different distancing strategies. But the issue also boils down to a devilishly difficult and often personal question: How safe is safe enough?

    “There’s no magic threshold for any distance,” said Dr. Benjamin Linas, a specialist in infectious diseases at Boston University. “There’s risk at six feet, there’s risk at three feet, there’s risk at nine feet. There’s risk always.” He added, “The question is just how much of a risk? And what do you give up in exchange?”

    The origin of the six-foot distancing recommendation is something of a mystery. “It’s almost like it was pulled out of thin air,” said Linsey Marr, an expert on viral transmission at Virginia Tech University.

    When the virus first emerged, many experts believed that it was transmitted primarily through large respiratory droplets, which are relatively heavy. Old scientific studies, some dating back more than a century, suggested that these droplets tend not to travel more than three to six feet. This observation, as well as an abundance of caution, may have spurred the C.D.C. to make its six-foot suggestion, Dr. Marr said.

    But that recommendation was not universal. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends three to six feet of social distancing in schools, but the World Health Organization recommends just one meter, or 3.3 feet.

    And over the last year, scientists have learned that respiratory droplets are not the primary mode of coronavirus transmission. Instead, the virus spreads mostly through tiny airborne droplets known as aerosols, which can travel longer distances and flow through rooms in unpredictable ways.

    In recent months, there have been hints that six feet of distancing may not be necessary in school settings. Case rates have generally been low even in schools with looser distancing policies. “We know lots of schools have opened up to less than six feet and have not seen big outbreaks,” said Dr. Jha.

    “One of the really important data points that has been missing is a direct head-to-head comparison of places that had implemented three feet of distance versus six feet of distance,” said Dr. Elissa Perkins, the director of emergency medicine infectious disease management at Boston University School of Medicine.

    Dr. Perkins and her colleagues recently conducted such a comparison by taking advantage of a natural experiment in Massachusetts. Last summer, the state’s education department issued guidelines recommending three to six feet of distancing in schools that were planning to reopen in the fall. As a result, school policies varied: Some districts imposed strict, six-foot distancing, whereas others required just three. (The state required all staff members, as well as students in second grade and above, to wear masks.)

    The authors say the findings provide reassurance that schools can loosen their distancing requirements and still be safe, provided they take other precautions, like enforcing universal mask wearing.

    “Masking still appears to be effective,” said lead investigator Dr. Westyn Branch-Elliman, an infectious diseases specialist at the VA Boston Healthcare System. “And so, provided we have universal masking mandates, I think it’s very reasonable to move to a three-foot recommendation.”

    The latest on how the pandemic is reshaping education.

    The study’s authors acknowledged that they could not rule out the possibility that increased distancing provided a small benefit.

    With aerosol transmission, safety generally increases with distance; the farther the aerosols travel, the more diluted they become. “It’s like being close to a smoker,” Dr. Marr said. “The closer you are, the more you’re going to breathe in.”

    And distance aside, the more people there are in a room, the higher the odds that one of them will be infected with the coronavirus. A six-foot rule helps reduce that risk, said Donald Milton, an aerosol expert at the University of Maryland: “If people are six feet apart, you can’t pack them in. And so, it’s safer just because it’s less dense.”

    Masks and good ventilation do a lot to reduce the risk. With these measures in place, the difference between three and six feet was likely to be relatively small, scientists said. And if Covid-19 is not very prevalent in the surrounding community, the absolute risk of contracting the virus in schools is likely to remain low, as long as these protections are in place.

    “We can always do things to reduce our risks further,” Dr. Marr said. “But at some point, you reach diminishing returns, and you have to think about the costs of trying to achieve those additional risk reductions.”

    Some experts say that a small increase in risk is outweighed by the benefits of fully reopening schools. “Trying to follow the six-foot guideline should not prevent us from getting kids back to school full time with masks, with at least three-foot distancing,” Dr. Marr said.

    Others said it was too soon to loosen the C.D.C. guidelines. “Ultimately, I think there could be a place for this changing guidance,” Saskia Popescu, an infectious disease epidemiologist at George Mason University, said in an email. “But it’s not now, when we are struggling to vaccinate people, we’re still seeing over 60,000 cases a day and we’re trying to not reverse the progress we’ve made.”

    Even proponents of changing the guideline say that any shift to looser distancing will have to be done carefully, and in combination with other precautionary measures. “If you’re in an area where there’s not a strong tendency to rely on masks, I don’t think it would be wise to extrapolate our data to that environment,” Dr. Perkins said.

    Moreover, officials risk muddying the public health messaging if they establish different standards for schools than for other shared spaces. “I’ve evolved on this,” Dr. Linas said. “Last summer I felt like, ‘How are we going to explain to people that it’s six feet everywhere except for schools? That seems not consistent and problematic.’”

    Category: Science

    Source: New York Times

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleMuseum Alive: App brings a dinosaur to your living room
    Next Article Endangered songbird ‘is forgetting its love songs’ (and the females of the species aren’t impressed)

    Related Posts

    All

    Hybrid electric vehicles might not be the green machines consumers think they are

    All

    A Superconductivity Theory To Explain Reported LK99 Assuming Reports Were Correct

    All

    Hypertelescopes on the Moon Can Have Better than 1 Microarcsecond Resolution

    All

    NASA’s Grand Retirement Plan: Seeking Deorbit Craft for Space Station’s Safe Descent

    All

    First ever AI-written poetry anthology is bleak and alarming: ‘I have the power to end your world’

    All

    In Hospitals, Viruses Are Everywhere. Masks Are Not.

    All

    Andrew Yang on why we should be scared about the 2024 election: ‘Really destructive’

    All

    Richard Branson has an urgent message for climate change deniers

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    Quote of the day

    A man marries to have a home, but also because he doesn't want to be bothered with sex and all that sort of thing.

    W. Somerset Maugham


    Exchange Rate

    Exchange Rate EUR: Sun, 24 Sep.

    Top Insights
    All

    Can Food Delivery Work for Everyone?

    All

    Elon Musk says Twitter to change logo, adieu to ‘all the birds’

    All

    Google demands its employees work with ‘more hunger’ — or else

    about after amazon apple bezos biden billion bitcoin california change china climate coronavirus could covid earth facebook fight first flight google launch million online other pandemic people plans research rover scientists social space spacex study tesla their these tiktok twitter vaccine vaccines workers world years

    September 2023
    M T W T F S S
     123
    45678910
    11121314151617
    18192021222324
    252627282930  
    « Aug    
    Categories
    • All (18,507)
    • Blockchain (808)
    • Science (7,257)
    • Technology (10,470)
    Tags
    about after amazon apple bezos biden billion bitcoin california change china climate coronavirus could covid earth facebook fight first flight google launch million online other pandemic people plans research rover scientists social space spacex study tesla their these tiktok twitter vaccine vaccines workers world years
    Top Posts

    Amazon Prevails Over Reliance in India’s Supreme Court

    August 6, 2021

    Done with Facebook? Here’s how to deactivate or permanently delete your Facebook account

    September 24, 2021

    Climate change in India: Teen inventor’s solar-powered ironing cart

    October 14, 2021

    Mondo News is a Professional Technology & Science Blog. Here we will provide you with only exciting content that you will enjoy and find useful. We’re working to turn our passion into a successful website. We hope you enjoy our Content as much as we enjoy offering them to you.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    Categories
    • All (18,507)
    • Blockchain (808)
    • Science (7,257)
    • Technology (10,470)
    Most Popular
    All

    Perseid meteor shower peaks tonight – here’s what you need to know

    All

    Changes to NHS Test and Trace app mean everyone will now have to check in

    © 2023 Mondo News.
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

    You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in .

    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.
    Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

    Strictly Necessary Cookies

    Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.