Ministers from Panama and several influential European Union countries are demanding that the final climate agreement include a commitment to phase out oil, gas and coal. Their opposition emerged after fossil-fuel-producing countries led by Saudi Arabia called for a withdrawal from oil, gas and coal, while negotiators also debated clean-energy targets and funding for developing nations.
Dispute over fossil fuels
Panama’s Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro said the proposed agreement was unacceptable because it failed to clearly address fossil fuels.
“COPs and cover-up decisions that don’t even mention fossil fuels are unacceptable and we will not put up with them,” Navarro said.
His criticism was echoed by Monique Barbu, France’s Minister of Environment and Transition. She said the text’s reference to carbon capture, utilization and storage—technologies designed to capture emissions as they are released and store them underground—could give countries permission to continue burning oil and gas.
“We cannot announce to the world that temperatures are rising by 1.5 degrees Celsius and then go about our business as if nothing has happened,” Barbu said.
Spain, France, Belgium, Sweden and Finland were among the EU member states calling for a final deal that explicitly commits to withdrawing from fossil fuels.
Acknowledging the 1.5-degree limit
The agreement, officially known as the Antalya Accord, was the first COP to acknowledge that the goal of limiting global temperature rise to below 1.5 degrees Celsius has not been met.
The world is entering a period known as “overshoot.” Scientists warn that beyond this point, millions more people will be exposed to rising sea levels and extreme heat.
The BBC understands that many other EU countries were asked to join the opposition but declined, believing that doing so would not help the negotiations.
One chief negotiator said he sympathized with the critics, but added: “How can you get a climate change deal without ever mentioning the causes?”
Focus on implementation and funding
Australian Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen, who is leading the negotiations, objected to the push for stronger fossil-fuel language. He said the COP should focus on implementation and on moving to clean energy sources.
One proposal is understood to involve Saudi Arabia and other petrostates removing fossil fuels from the negotiations in exchange for signing a pledge to generate 35% of their electricity from electricity by 2035.
That proposal would not resolve another major concern raised by developing countries: a lack of funding.
An earlier version of the document included an agreement to increase adaptation funding to $120 billion by 2035, but that commitment has since been removed.
“We are not here to beg. We are here to claim what is rightfully ours for our people who are bearing the brunt of the human activities of developed countries,” said Zanetor Agyemang Rawlings, Ghana’s Minister of the Environment and Chair of the African Negotiating Group.
Source: www.bbc.co.uk












