The Federal Communications Commission has ordered California to stop enforcing its carrier of last resort (COLR) requirements against AT&T, opening a new conflict between the Trump administration and the state over California’s authority to regulate telecommunications. AT&T, which is designated as California’s carrier of last resort, is currently required to provide telephone service to any potential customer within its territory. The company wants to stop offering basic landline service to new customers.
AT&T has sought approval to cancel the service beginning June 1, 2027. Under the proposal, 184,000 residential customers and 15,000 business customers would be eligible for the change. California’s rules require AT&T to continue serving customers unless it can provide an approved replacement that meets the state’s standards for basic telephone service.
In an order released today, the FCC granted AT&T’s request to preempt California’s COLR rules, following the agency’s earlier approval of the company’s request to suspend service. AT&T had pursued a similar outcome in court, but a federal judge rejected the company’s request in July to invalidate California’s requirements.
The FCC’s decision may not be final. California could sue the commission over the order. The state is the only one among the 21 states in AT&T’s wireline coverage area where the company has not received reduced COLR obligations.
Kerr says California rules were “designed for a bygone era”
“California’s carrier of last resort framework may have made sense when it was established 30 years ago,” FCC Chairman Brendan Kerr said in a statement accompanying the order. “But those rules were designed for a bygone era and are no longer relevant in today’s competitive, developed markets.”
If AT&T retires its older copper-based telephone service, many homes and businesses may not have access to a modern fiber-optic connection. AT&T argued, and the FCC agreed, that wireless home-phone service connected to cellular networks can serve as a sufficient replacement.
“The FCC has granted AT&T an application to replace traditional voice services with modern IP-based alternatives in certain areas of the state. California’s requirements prevent AT&T from proceeding with a federally approved transition,” Kerr said.
California’s rules allow wireless replacements if they meet the state’s standards for basic telephone service, but they require AT&T to demonstrate that its wireless service fulfills the company’s COLR obligations. Those requirements include flat-rate plans with unlimited voice calls, reduced Lifeline rates for eligible low-income customers, and telephone relay services for people who are deaf or hard of hearing.
California has detailed the rules in its proceedings on AT&T’s applications to discontinue landline voice service.
Source: arstechnica.com












