Climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, collapsed on Sunday after the European Union and other countries rejected a proposed agreement that did not mention reducing dependence on fossil fuels. Representatives of 196 countries and the European Union had been trying to agree on new climate commitments and ways to implement earlier pledges, but negotiations ended without consensus.
Negotiations end without agreement
COP31 President Murat Krum said Sunday, two days after the meeting was scheduled to end, that there would be no new draft agreement after negotiators rejected the fourth version.
“There’s nothing we can do. We did everything we could,” said Krum, Turkey’s environment minister. “We do not perform new text work in an environment where there is no consensus.”
COP31 negotiators’ chair Chris Bowen told reporters that discussions had reached a “red line that cannot be crossed.”
“The circumstances leading into this COP were some of the most complex and challenging geopolitical environments in living memory,” said Bowen, the Australian minister. “In past COPs, like the last two, where people wanted to mention certain words but didn’t understand, this time it became a line that couldn’t be crossed,” he added.
Fossil fuels remain a central dispute
The agreement’s latest draft, released Sunday, outlined measures for countries to accelerate climate action. But the 12-page document quickly drew criticism because it did not mention a key demand from the European Union and other countries: moving away from fossil fuels.
Irish Minister Darragh O’Brien, representing the EU in Antalya, said the bloc was “strongly opposed” to the deal and called it “greenwashing.”
“These decisions fall far short of the level of ambition needed to tackle climate change. It would be unconscionable to have a climate change agreement that does not mention fossil fuels,” O’Brien said.
Panama also rejected the deal, saying it did not go far enough.
“Science doesn’t negotiate,” he said. “The Earth cannot continue to wait.”
British mission spokeswoman Kate Hughes said the situation “requires greater ambition” and described the draft as the “lowest common denominator.”
“What we have in front of us is not commensurate with the urgency of the overshoot, the scale of the climate crisis, and the impacts already being felt by the most vulnerable people and communities around the world,” she told the conference.
The Marshall Islands, a low-lying Pacific nation facing an existential threat from rising sea levels, also rejected the agreement.
Talks extended beyond scheduled end
Every country had to approve the document for it to pass. The talks became the longest in COP history, surpassing the delay in negotiations at COP25 in Madrid.
The summit began on November 9th. The first draft, circulated a week later, mentioned “fossil fuels” six times. However, the second draft, released on Thursday, removed all references, angering many countries.
The meeting officially ended on Friday without an agreement. Member states continued negotiating in an effort to find a solution, but the fourth draft published Sunday still did not mention fossil fuels.
Saudi Arabia, Russia and India have resisted including references to fossil fuels, expressing concern that phasing them out could create fiscal risks because they are central to their economies.
The United States, one of the largest greenhouse gas emitters, was officially absent from the conference after withdrawing from a series of international climate commitments under President Donald Trump.
Concerns over the 1.5-degree target
The latest draft began with a “full recall of the UAE agreement,” referring to the outcome of the UAE’s COP28, when countries first agreed to “de-transition” from fossil fuels in their energy systems.
The draft also acknowledged that the goal established in the 2015 Paris Agreement of limiting global temperature rise to below 1.5 degrees Celsius will not be met.
If warming exceeds 1.5 degrees Celsius, the effects of climate change, including heatwaves and other extreme weather events, are expected to increase significantly.
If negotiations break down, Krum could convene a follow-up meeting or postpone a decision until next year’s conference, which will be hosted by Ethiopia.
The last time climate negotiations broke down was at COP6 in The Hague, Netherlands, in 2000.
Source: www.nbcnews.com












