The results of the US midterm elections could lead to changes in Congress and influence how science is governed. Credit: Aaron E. Martinez/The Austin American-Statesman via Getty
A landslide victory for the US Democratic Party, giving it majorities in both chambers of Congress, has renewed optimism among scientists about the future of the country’s research system. Science advocates and lawmakers are now focused on the fiscal year 2027 spending bill, while also confronting longer-term questions about who should help make decisions on science and technology and how policymakers can bring more public voices into the process.
These issues lie at the center of science’s “social contract”: a government-supported system in which taxpayers fund research and scientists retain autonomy in exchange for the promise of public benefits. The debate also reaches beyond the arguments surrounding the Second World War that helped establish the modern US research system. At its core are older questions about how science should be governed and what role experts should play in a democracy.
Reconsidering the social contract for science
Postwar US science policy has generally given experts more influence than the public. Eighty years after the publication of scientific adviser Vannevar Bush’s report Science, the Endless Frontier, the government has tested policy mechanisms intended to bring research into closer alignment with the country’s social and economic needs. Public participation, however, remains at an early stage.
The National Science Foundation (NSF), the main funder of basic university research, has come to embody the US social contract for science. Federal science policy has also become a battleground between the priorities of academia and those of the White House.
NSF faces funding and leadership uncertainty
The NSF has no Senate-confirmed director, and its acting director is scheduled to retire at the end of the year, leaving the agency with a widening leadership gap. The American Institute of Physics and others reported on the April dismissal of the National Science Board, which helps oversee the NSF. Agency observers say that the absence of a Senate-confirmed director leaves the foundation more vulnerable to direction from the White House.
The NSF awarded nearly 50% fewer grants in fiscal year 2026 than it did from 2021 through 2024. The agency has also announced that it carried more than $1 billion into fiscal year 2027 to support priorities aligned with broader initiatives of President Donald Trump’s administration. Although research funding is subject to a two-year spending deadline, a large share of an annual budget is not typically carried forward.
A window for reform
During the past two years, the Trump administration has reshaped the country’s long-standing social contract for science and the close partnership between universities and the federal government. The effects on US science, together with growing public attention to science policy, have created an unusual opportunity for reform.
When the 120th Congress convenes on January 3, it will need to decide how much funding research receives in fiscal year 2027 and address broader questions about public participation in science and technology policy. Congress should use the opportunity to rethink the nation’s science-policy institutions rather than simply trying to reassemble them.
Source: www.nature.com












