Feedback is New Scientist. A well-respected platform delivering the latest in science and technology updates. If you have insights to share, please send your feedback to feedback@newscientist.com.
Exploring the Lunar Economy
The moon captivates our imagination and stimulates forward-thinking discussions. Enthusiasts are optimistic about the prospects of our natural satellite, yet it raises questions about potential distractions.
In a recent letter dated March 21, we highlighted the ambitions of accounting giant PwC to assess the future of the lunar economy. Their projections suggest a market worth billions, despite current lunar operations totaling nearly $0.00.
Further insights from SpaceNews reveal significant developments involving the U.S. Space Force—a new military branch focusing on the cislunar space. Their Coordination Bureau aims to evaluate the strategic importance of the lunar region for national security and military operations.
Consider a hypothetical situation where the U.S. establishes a lunar base. How will such an asset be protected to ensure safe resupply missions? This may require the Space Force to exercise operational control over lunar environments.
As discussions about potential lunar conflicts emerge, we discovered a book released in 2025: Space Piracy: Preparing for a Criminal Crisis in Orbit by Mark Feldman and Hugh Taylor. The authors propose that space piracy could be executed by criminal enterprises or rogue nations seeking profit in outer space, raising concerns about cybersecurity and resource blockades.
Feldman and Taylor have established the Center for the Study of Space Crime, Piracy, and Governance to explore these possibilities further.
In light of our feedback, we’ve questioned whether we are overly critical of technological advancements. Historically, skeptics doubted the feasibility of powered flight and the significance of computers. While the Moon isn’t a current epicenter for profit or conflict, this could change in the future.
For a counterpoint, we referenced an academic review by retired U.S. Air Force officer Mark T. Peters II. Peters expresses skepticism about the practicality of space piracy scenarios, aside from known cyber threats, suggesting the book lacks a feasible approach.
From our engagement, it remains unclear whether this policy is an innovative approach or merely an excuse for workshops that detract from core objectives. While the theory may not be valid, the discourse is enticing, and participation would be exciting.
The Math Doesn’t Add Up
Feedback aims to provide clarity, not obfuscation. This segment underwent revisions when we misrepresented certain statistics.
The matter in question involves comments from U.S. Secretary of Health Robert F. Kennedy Jr. He claimed that raising a drug price from $100 to $600 represents a 600% increase, while a drop to $100 suggests a similar savings.
It has been highlighted that the reduction from $600 to $100 does not translate to a 600% decrease—a drop of 100% leads to $0.00. However, we also miscalculated the original increase.
Our sincere thanks to Chris Smart, who pointed out, “An increase from $100 to $600 is $500, equating to a 500% increase.” Therefore, both the premise and conclusion are inaccurate, rendering them insignificant.
Tom Brock clarifies the confusion surrounding percentage increases and base values, highlighting that an increase from $100 to $600 is indeed a 500% rise, not 600% as claimed.
Journalists are often advised to avoid discussing percentages due to the potential for misunderstanding, sticking instead to whole numbers for better clarity—although our audience seemed completely aware of the inaccuracies in this instance.
This is humbling, but thankfully, both Feedback and RFK Jr. occupy low-stakes roles.
The Book Lover’s Dilemma
Recommendation algorithms are evolving to better align with user preferences. Discovering content that resonates with our interests is one thing, but receiving curated stories on a platter is another. Our podcast app has recently identified our interest in the off the shelf podcast, which delves into books and publishing.
The host’s name, Morgan Book, aptly reflects the podcast’s focus, leading to humorous yet genuine brand recognition in her promotional materials.
Do you have a story to share with Feedback?
Feel free to send your article to Feedback via email at feedback@newscientist.com, ensuring to include your home address. Check our website for this week’s and previous editions of Feedback.
Source: www.newscientist.com
