Doctoral students at Indonesian universities say supervision is often poor and that some supervisors engage in inappropriate behavior.Credit: epsgalery85/Shutterstock
Indonesia is seeking to increase the number of people earning doctorates from about 75,000 to 125,000 by 2045, but doctoral students and academics say many universities lack the supervision and academic oversight needed to support that expansion. Students describe brief, formal meetings with supervisors, substantial power imbalances, requests to pay research costs and cases of inappropriate behavior, raising concerns about the quality of the country’s doctoral training.
When Ruli Charitas Prahmana travelled to the United States as a guest lecturer, she experienced a striking academic culture shock. “I was surprised to see my supervisor go cycling with his doctoral students on the weekends,” says Prahmana, a mathematics lecturer at Ahmad Dahlan University in Yogyakarta, Indonesia, and a visiting scholar at Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo.
Prahmana says she cannot imagine such interactions at home. She is among the minority of academics who occasionally have informal discussions with students outside the classroom, such as at warung, the small food stalls and restaurants found throughout Indonesia. Many of her colleagues, she says, never meet students in a casual setting.
Relationships between doctoral candidates and supervisors in Indonesia often involve less direct scientific guidance in the laboratory and less oversight of the overall research project than is typical in many doctoral programmes elsewhere. Instead, many junior researchers say they meet their supervisors only for short, formal discussions, to sign a research proposal or to approve a thesis. Students at larger and more prestigious institutions might receive more direct instruction, but “most of the time what we have is a power asymmetry,” Prahmana says.
“I met with my supervisors regularly, but instead of mentoring me, they gossiped about other instructors,” says one of the 11 PhD students interviewed for this article. Several students requested anonymity to protect their careers.
Some students said they had been asked to take on work at their own expense. One interviewee said they had to pay for access to sampling sites before conducting wet-lab studies. “I need to withdraw Rp 200,000” — around US$12 — “We sampled each location week after week for a year,” the student said. In total, she spent about $1,700 a year on sampling. The average monthly salary in Indonesia is approximately $200.
“I think there are many professors who treat their students unfairly,” said an anonymous student from Semarang, Indonesia.
“But we just want to graduate early, so we have no choice but to accept what the boss says,” said another.
Population bonus
Some young academics attribute poor leadership to weak management of Indonesia’s doctoral programmes. The programmes aim to increase the number of doctoral graduates from about 75,000 to 125,000 by 2045.
Brian Uriart, Indonesia’s minister of higher education, science and technology, said the goal would help drive economic growth. Although national statistical data are patchy and large-scale censuses take place only every 10 years, Indonesia is estimated to have 64 million people aged between 16 and 30. Uriart described this group, which represents 22% of the country’s population, as a “demographic bonus”. He argued that Indonesia needed to “transform them into highly skilled human resources”.
Indonesia currently has 272 PhDs per million people, compared with about 14,000 PhDs per million people in the United States.
My relationship with my supervisor in the doctoral programme deteriorated. What should I do?
To increase the number further, the Indonesian Education Endowment Fund, which manages the country’s $9.1 million endowment, has set aside funding for an additional 2,500 doctoral scholarships this year, Uriart said. Nearly half are for people seeking doctoral opportunities abroad. The remainder will go to students studying partly or fully in Indonesia.
However, only some Indonesian universities are equipped to provide enough supervision to double the number of people earning high-quality PhDs, argues Berry Juliandi, dean of the Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences at IPB University in Bogor. He says the new funding is not accompanied by strategic policies and regulations to improve academic oversight at the country’s universities, and therefore will not ensure a high-quality PhD experience.
Indonesia has 4,303 higher-education institutions. The country’s National Higher Education Accreditation Agency classifies only 226 as “highly qualified”. The assessment considers not only physical infrastructure, but also an institution’s scientific reputation and the experience and teaching skills of its instructors.
Fikri Yanda, a PhD student at Warairak University in Taiburi, Thailand, runs the pembela_mahasiswa_indonesia Instagram account, which discusses Indonesian academia. He says conflicts between supervisors and PhD students are also widespread at highly qualified institutions.

Luli Charitas Prahumana, a mathematics professor at Ahmad Dahlan University in Yogyakarta, Indonesia, says there is often a power asymmetry between PhD supervisors and students in Indonesia.Credit: Rully Charitas Indra Prahmana
So far this year, Indonesia’s Ministry of Education has reported 874 cases of inappropriate behavior, including ethical misconduct, violence, sexual harassment and abuse of authority.
Andik Wijayanto, a biology doctoral student at Gadjah Mada University in Yogyakarta, said such behavior “hinders our freedom to think freely as academics” because scientists cannot challenge the status quo. Many students are afraid of making mistakes, he says. Wijayanto also teaches biology at Malang State University in East Java and says he has had no problems with his supervisor.
Publishing practices
In 2017, Indonesia’s Ministry of Higher Education reported that 3,800 of the country’s 5,366 professors had not published peer-reviewed papers in international journals considered reliable by the government. The finding led to stricter regulations requiring all professors and other university lecturers with master’s or doctoral degrees, in any field, to publish in high-quality journals indexed by Scopus.
However, the policy had unintended consequences. Some academics turned to predatory journals — organisations that charge authors to publish papers without providing legitimate peer review or adequate editorial support, often using aggressive or misleading solicitation practices. Some researchers also manipulated citation indices to obtain higher performance scores in government evaluation systems.
In 2021, the ministry introduced scientific-integrity regulations that impose sanctions on scientists involved in data fabrication, plagiarism or falsification of authorship. Another regulation, signed by Uriart in February, requires institutions to assess “scientific integrity” when evaluating university lecturers’ performance. These evaluations influence researchers’ career opportunities.
My principal investigator does not provide any support or guidance regarding my PhD project. What should I do?
Source: www.nature.com












