Birdfy’s Rookie smart bird feeder combines a simple design with the company’s well-made app, but four weeks of testing revealed compromises in image quality, motion detection, weather protection, lid stability, camera placement, and battery life. Its 1.3-liter seed capacity and subscription-free bird identification are useful advantages, while the camera produced well-framed images of smaller birds and the app made it easy to monitor visitors.
Design and camera limitations
The Rookie’s 1080p camera produced noticeably lower-quality images than the Nook’s. Although it captured every bird that visited, it also generated many false motion detections.
The feeder itself has an IP66 water-resistance rating, but its design has an important weakness: There is no roof overhang, allowing rain to seep into the seeds. It rained intermittently during the testing period.
The lid also rests loosely on top of the feeder, so strong winds can blow it off. The side-mounted camera was not especially effective at capturing large birds, although its lens stayed relatively clean and was positioned far enough from the activity to avoid much of the movement. Images of smaller birds were nicely framed.
Birdfy advertises up to seven weeks of battery life, but the test unit lasted less than two weeks.
Seed capacity and app features
One of the Rookie’s main advantages is its seed capacity. At 1.3 liters, it is only slightly smaller than Birdfy’s popular original feeder, which holds 1.5 liters. That capacity is still much lower than the 3.5-liter bamboo feeder, the top pick in the Best Smart Bird Feeder Guide.
Capacity aside, Birdfy’s app is well designed and straightforward. It makes it easy to see which birds visited during the day. Owners of a Roku can also watch the feeder on a television; the Birdfy app supports devices running Roku OS 15.1 or later.
As of November 1, Birdfy was offering unlimited automated, AI-based bird identification without a subscription. That is uncommon among smart bird feeders. Birdfy’s identification was fairly accurate, with very few errors during testing.
Source: www.wired.com










