San Diego has rejected a proposal involving Flock Safety license-plate-reading cameras and Ubiquia “smart street lights,” despite police representatives telling the City Council that vehicle thefts have fallen 20 percent since 2023 and that Flock cameras helped recover 689 stolen vehicles.
San Diego rejects the technology
The council’s vote marks a significant change from three years ago, when San Diego officials approved a program involving the technology. The city’s rejection included Ubiquia’s smart street lights, which use Flock’s artificial-intelligence-powered automatic license-plate reader (ALPR) software. Flock Safety and Ubiquia previously described the systems as working together to provide police with license-plate information and other evidence.
The decision is the second time in less than a decade that San Diego has experimented with and ultimately rejected smart-street-light technology.
San Diego previously purchased thousands of smart street-light systems from GE Current, but the administration of the previous mayor shut them down in 2020. Ubiquia later acquired CityIQ, developed a smart-city platform, partnered with Flock, and—with support from the police—proposed installing 500 new cameras in 2023.
Privacy concerns
At the time, the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Commission, a local watchdog group, urged the City Council to reject the plan. Pega Parsi, a member of the commission, said she now feels “vindicated,” according to a LinkedIn post.
“A reminder to all cities, agencies, and agencies: If you establish an advisory board of experts, listen to it,” Parsi wrote. “Actually, listen seriously. It’s cheaper than learning the hard way. Try harder.”
Secure Justice, an Oakland-based advocacy group that studies and monitors the use of Flock systems across the country, expressed a similar view.
“We have recorded at least 513 swarms. It’s over in red and blue states, big cities and small cities. It’s clear that Americans don’t consent to the government tracking them as we go about our daily lives,” Brian Hofer, the group’s executive director, told Ars in an email.
Source: arstechnica.com












