What is Cloud Seeding and Could It Solve Iran’s Drought Crisis?

SEI 274681593

Riverbed near Latian Dam, one of Tehran’s main water sources, Iran

BAHRAM/Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images

Iran faces an extreme drought, prompting the president to suggest a possible evacuation of Tehran. To mitigate the situation, cloud-seeding aircraft will start operations on November 15, set to persist through the rainy season until May. However, experts caution that this method is complex and unlikely to significantly alleviate the water crisis on its own.

How critical is the drought in Iran?

Iran’s rainfall is down by 85 percent, with Tehran registering only 1 mm this year. Local reservoirs are reported to be in a dire condition, with 32 dams barely holding 5 percent of their capacity. Satellite imagery shows some areas completely parched.

Residents of Tehran have cut their water usage by approximately 10 percent, yet this reduction falls short. Water pressure has diminished overnight, and officials are preparing to fine households and businesses that exceed their water limits. The president indicated that if rains do not increase by December, 14 million people in Tehran might need to relocate.

What are the causes of drought?

Experts attribute the drought, which has persisted for five years, to climate change. This autumn is the driest Iran has seen in 50 years, with temperatures reaching above 15°C (59°F) in Tehran, a city usually experiencing snowfall in November.

However, mismanagement is largely to blame. Kave Madani, a former environmental ministry official, labels Iran a “water bankrupt.” The government has expanded agriculture in arid regions excessively, stressing water resources. A staggering number of illegal wells—around half a million—have been drilled by desperate farmers, draining groundwater supplies.

What exactly is cloud seeding?

Cloud seeding originated in the 1940s with scientists like Bernard Vonnegut, brother of author Kurt Vonnegut. The process involves dispersing particles that encourage water droplets in clouds to precipitate as rain. While some studies have experimented with salt, the focus has generally been on spraying silver iodide into upper-level mixed-phase clouds. When supercooled liquid droplets encounter this crystalline material, they crystallize into ice that ultimately falls as rain or snow.

Determining the amount of precipitation caused by cloud seeding can be challenging, especially in the absence of cloud formation.

“The natural variability of clouds is significant, making it tough to quantify their impacts,” says Andrea Frosman from the University of Clermont-Auvergne, France. “Externally, clouds appear, but not all of them bring rain.”

A 2014 experiment conducted in Wyoming indicated that cloud seeding could enhance precipitation by 5 to 15 percent.

Is there hope for resolving the drought?

Previously, Iran blamed Israel and the United Arab Emirates for “stealing” rain via cloud seeding, but it’s now taking matters into its own hands. It plans to deploy cargo planes, drones, and a “ground generator”, which is essentially a smoker’s oven, commonly located in mountainous regions.

On November 15, clouds formed over the watershed surrounding Lake Urmia, which has been barren for over two decades, now reduced to a salt flat littered with decaying boats. Initial reports suggest that areas west of the lake received up to 2.7 centimeters of rain the following morning, as indicated by a precipitation map from the University of California, Irvine.

Success in cloud seeding depends on the presence of moisture-rich clouds, which might be sparse in arid Iran, where large bodies of water are limited.

“Cloud seeding becomes particularly challenging during droughts, owing to the extremely dry atmosphere that may not support moisture-laden clouds,” notes Karen Howard, a scientist with the U.S. General Accounting Office.

Yet, in recent days, numerous rain clouds have poured into Iran from the Black Sea, causing localized flooding in regions such as Iram and Kurdistan on November 16.

Cloud seeding might help “extract a few additional droplets” from these weather systems, according to Armin Sorooshian at the University of Arizona. “While it won’t create flooding or completely solve the drought issue, it may provide a minor benefit.”

topic:

Source: www.newscientist.com

UAE government denies cloud seeding occurred prior to Dubai floods

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates – The National Meteorological Center, the government task force responsible for cloud seeding missions in the United Arab Emirates, stated that they did not carry out any weather modification techniques in anticipation of severe storms that led to flooding in places like Dubai.

According to CNBC, the group confirmed that they did not deploy pilots for seeding operations before or during the storm that affected the UAE on that fateful Tuesday.

Omar Al-Yazidi, deputy director of NCM, emphasized that no seeding operations were conducted during the storm, stating, “If you find yourself in severe thunderstorm conditions, you should carry out seeding operations before the rain falls. It’s too late.”

On Tuesday, the UAE experienced heavy rainfall. NCM reported that Al Ain received 10 inches of rainfall, while Dubai saw over 100 mm. This is significantly higher than the average annual rainfall in the UAE, which ranges from 140 to 200mm.

NCM’s statement contradicted previous reports suggesting that some of the rain was caused by cloud seeding. The process of cloud seeding has been a crucial aspect of the UAE’s efforts to combat water scarcity since the 1990s, with over 1,000 hours of cloud seeding conducted annually.

The increase in precipitation is attributed to climate change, with a study projecting a 30% increase in precipitation by 2080. This shift in weather patterns has posed challenges for the UAE’s infrastructure, especially in managing drainage systems during heavy downpours.

The UAE government issued warnings through the National Emergency Crisis and Disaster Management Authority, advising residents to adhere to safety guidelines due to the extreme weather conditions.

Despite the region’s unique weather patterns, the UAE’s drainage systems struggled to handle the unprecedented rainfall, leading to flooding in many areas, including Dubai Airport.

Source: www.nbcnews.com

Cloud Seeding: An Explanation and its Potential Role in the Dubai Floods

Driver abandons car after rainstorm in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, April 17

Christopher Pike/Bloomberg/Getty

Record rainfall has hit the Arabian Peninsula this week, causing flooding in Dubai, Abu Dhabi and other coastal cities in the United Arab Emirates. The extreme weather sparked speculation on social media that the UAE’s long-standing cloud seeding program may have played a role. However, cloud seeding almost certainly does not have a significant impact on flooding.

How unusual was the recent rain in the Arabian Peninsula?

It was the most extreme event in the UAE since record-keeping began in 1949. according to to the state-run Emirates News Agency. From April 15th to 16th, some parts of the country received more than their normal annual rainfall in a 24-hour period. Heavy rains in desert regions are not uncommon, but they are not unheard of – as the UAE sees it. heavy rain and flooding For example, 2016.

A drainage system in a coastal city in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) has been overwhelmed by spills, causing flooding. Dramatic images of a plane driving through stagnant water at Dubai International Airport have been widely shared online.

In neighboring Oman, died in flash flood At least 18 people. Parts of Bahrain, Qatar and Saudi Arabia also experienced unusual rainfall.

What is cloud seeding? Did it affect extreme rain?

Cloud seeding is a way to increase precipitation, From about the 1940s. This involves spraying powders such as silver iodide onto clouds from airplanes or rockets, or burning them from stations on the ground. Droplets of supercooled water form around these particles and fall to the ground as rain or snow.

Since 2002, the UAE has maintained one of the largest cloud seeding programs in the world. Planes regularly fly cloud-seeding missions in an effort to increase freshwater resources in arid regions.

Meteorologists at the UAE’s National Center of Meteorology (NCM) have further fueled speculation that cloud formations may be responsible for the recent rains. Said bloomberg news That in the days before the storm, planes had spread clouds over the country. However, NCM later stated: statement That no seed was sown during the storm.

“We take the safety of our employees, pilots and aircraft very seriously,” the company said. “NCM does not conduct cloud seeding operations during extreme weather conditions.”

Even if cloud formation had occurred during the storm, it would have had at most a small effect on precipitation and would have been localized. The extent of rainfall across several countries and the generally limited influence of cloud species suggest that cloud occurrence almost certainly does not play a significant role. “There is no technology that can create or even significantly alter this type of rainfall event.” Maarten Ambaum at the University of Reading, UK statement.

He noted that cloud seeding would have little impact on clouds that were already predicted to bring rain to the region. And that assumes that cloud seeding is effective at all.

“Many claims of successful cloud seeding are false, scientifically flawed, or actually fraudulent,” he says. Andrew Dessler at Texas A&M University. “This makes most atmospheric scientists very skeptical about cloud formation.”

What weather factors were behind the rain?

The extreme precipitation was caused by large storms called mesoscale convective systems. Suzanne Gray Researchers at the University of Reading say this happens “when many individual thunderstorms coalesce to form a single large high-level cloud shield.”

Forecasters had predicted a high risk of flooding in the area for at least a week before the storm.Writing in progress XJeff Berardelli, a meteorologist at WFLA-TV in Florida, linked the storm to a blocking pattern created by a slow-moving jet stream.

Has climate change made rain worse?

Further analysis is needed to link this particular event to climate change, but climate change likely plays a role.

“These types of heavy rainfall events are likely to become more extreme with climate change, as a warming atmosphere retains more water vapor,” Ambaum said. Changes in temperature can also affect atmospheric circulation patterns in the form of changes in precipitation.

For example, recent study The same type of storm that caused this extreme rainfall has occurred in the region 95 times since 2000, with the most frequent occurrences on the Arabian Peninsula in March and April, researchers found. However, it has also been found that the duration of these storms has increased over the UAE since 2000, which may be linked to rising temperatures.

Alternative climate modeling study They predict that annual rainfall in the UAE will increase by 10 to 25 percent by mid-century, characterized by more intense precipitation events.

topic:

  • climate change/
  • Abnormal weather

Source: www.newscientist.com