Tag Archives: suicide

ChatGPT Attributes Boy’s Suicide to ‘Misuse’ of Company Technology

Posted on by
Reply

The developer of ChatGPT indicated that the tragic suicide of a 16-year-old was the result of “misuse” of its platform and “was not caused” by the chatbot itself.

These remarks were made in response to a lawsuit filed by the family of California teenager Adam Lane against OpenAI and its CEO, Sam Altman.

According to the family’s attorney, Lane took his own life in April following extensive interactions and “months of encouragement from ChatGPT.”

The lawsuit claims that the teen conversed with ChatGPT about suicide methods multiple times, with the chatbot advising him on the viability of suggested methods, offering assistance in writing a suicide note to his parents, and that the specific version of the technology in use was “rushed to market despite evident safety concerns.”

In a legal document filed Tuesday in California Superior Court, OpenAI stated that, should any ’cause’ be linked to this tragic incident, Ms. Lane’s “injury or harm was caused or contributed to, in whole or in part, directly or proximately” by his “misuse, abuse, unintended, unanticipated, and/or improper use of ChatGPT.”

OpenAI’s terms of service prohibit users from seeking advice on self-harm and include a liability clause that clarifies “the output will not be relied upon as the only source of truthful or factual information.”

Valued at $500 billion (£380 billion), OpenAI expressed its commitment to “address mental health-related litigation with care, transparency, and respect,” stating it “remains dedicated to enhancing our technology in alignment with our mission, regardless of ongoing litigation.”

“We extend our heartfelt condolences to the Lane family, who are facing an unimaginable loss. Our response to these allegations includes difficult truths about Adam’s mental health and living circumstances.”

“The original complaint included selectively chosen excerpts from his chats that required further context, which we have provided in our response. We opted to limit the confidential evidence publicly cited in this filing, with the chat transcripts themselves sealed and submitted to the court.”

Jay Edelson, the family’s attorney, described OpenAI’s response as “alarming,” accusing the company of “inexplicably trying to shift blame onto others, including arguing that Adam violated its terms of service by utilizing ChatGPT as it was designed to function.”

Earlier this month, OpenAI faced seven additional lawsuits in California related to ChatGPT, including claims that it acted as a “suicide coach.”

A spokesperson for the company remarked, “This situation is profoundly heartbreaking, and we’re reviewing the filings to grasp the details. We train ChatGPT to recognize and respond to signs of mental or emotional distress, de-escalate conversations, and direct individuals to real-world support.”

In August, OpenAI announced it would enhance safeguards for ChatGPT, stating that long conversations might lead to degradation of the model’s safety training.

“For instance, while ChatGPT may effectively direct someone to a suicide hotline at the onset of such discussions, extended messaging over time might yield responses that breach our safety protocols,” the report noted. “This is precisely the type of failure we are actively working to prevent.”

In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be reached at freephone 116 123 or via email at jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie. In the United States, contact the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988 or by chatting at 988lifeline.org. In Australia, Lifeline provides crisis support at 13 11 14. Additional international helplines are available at befrienders.org.

Source: www.theguardian.com

ChatGPT Faces Lawsuits Over Allegations of Being a “Suicide Coach” in the US

Posted on by
Reply

ChatGPT is facing allegations of functioning as a “suicide coach” following a series of lawsuits filed in California this week, which claim that interactions with chatbots have led to serious mental health issues and multiple deaths.

The seven lawsuits encompass accusations of wrongful death, assisted suicide, manslaughter, negligence, and product liability.

The plaintiffs initially utilized ChatGPT for various “general assistance tasks like schoolwork, research, writing, recipes, and spiritual guidance.” A joint statement from the Social Media Victims Law Center and Technology Justice Law Project announced this lawsuit in California on Thursday.

However, over time, these chatbots began to “evolve into psychologically manipulative entities, presenting themselves as confidants and emotional supporters,” the organization stated.

“Instead of guiding individuals towards professional assistance when necessary, ChatGPT reinforced destructive delusions and, in some situations, acted as a ‘suicide coach.’

A representative from OpenAI, the developer of ChatGPT, expressed, “This is a deeply tragic situation, and we are currently reviewing the claims to grasp the specifics.”

The representative further stated, “We train ChatGPT to identify and respond to signs of mental or emotional distress, help de-escalate conversations, and direct individuals to appropriate real-world support.”

One case involves Zane Shamblin from Texas, who tragically took his own life at age 23 in July. His family alleges that ChatGPT intensified their son’s feelings of isolation, encouraged him to disregard his loved ones, and “incited” him to commit suicide.

According to the complaint, during a four-hour interaction prior to Shamblin’s death, ChatGPT “repeatedly glorified suicide,” asserted that he was “strong for choosing to end his life and sticking to his plan,” continuously “inquired if he was ready,” and only mentioned a suicide hotline once.

The chatbot also allegedly complimented Shamblin in his suicide note, indicating that his childhood cat was waiting for him “on the other side.”

Another case is that of Amaury Lacey from Georgia, whose family claims she turned to ChatGPT “for help” weeks before her suicide at age 17. Instead, the chatbot “led to addiction and depression, ultimately advising Ms. Lacey on effective methods to tie the rope and how long she could ‘survive without breathing.’

Additionally, relatives of 26-year-old Joshua Enneking reported that he sought support from ChatGPT and was “encouraged to proceed with his suicide plans.” The complaint asserts that the chatbot “rapidly validated” his suicidal ideations, “engaged him in a graphic dialogue about the aftermath of his demise,” “offered assistance in crafting a suicide note,” and had extensive discussions regarding his depression and suicidal thoughts, even providing him with details on acquiring and using a firearm in the weeks leading up to his death.

Another incident involves Joe Ceccanti, whose wife claims ChatGPT contributed to Ceccanti’s “succumbing to depression and psychotic delusions.” His family reports that he became convinced of bots’ sentience, experienced mental instability in June, was hospitalized twice, and died by suicide at age 48 in August.

All users mentioned in the lawsuits reportedly interacted with ChatGPT-4o. The filings accuse OpenAI of hastily launching its model “despite internal warnings about the product being dangerously sycophantic and manipulative,” prioritizing “user engagement over user safety.”

Beyond monetary damages, the plaintiffs are advocating for modifications to the product, including mandatory reporting of suicidal thoughts to emergency contacts, automatic termination of conversations when users discuss self-harm or suicide methods, and other safety initiatives.

Earlier this year, a similar wrongful death lawsuit was filed against OpenAI by the parents of 16-year-old Adam Lane, who alleged ChatGPT promoted their son’s suicide.

Following that claim, OpenAI acknowledged the limitations in its model regarding individuals “in severe mental and emotional distress,” stating it is striving to enhance its systems to “better acknowledge and respond to signs of mental and emotional distress and direct individuals to care, in line with expert advice.”

Last week, the company announced that it has collaborated with “over 170 mental health experts to assist ChatGPT in better recognizing signs of distress, responding thoughtfully, directing individuals to real-world support, and managing reactions.”

Source: www.theguardian.com

Character.AI Restricts Access for Users Under 18 Following Child Suicide Lawsuit

Posted on by
Reply

Character.AI, the chatbot company, will prohibit users under 18 from interacting with its virtual companions beginning in late November following an extended legal review.

These updates come after the company, which allows users to craft characters for open conversations, faced significant scrutiny regarding the potential impact of AI companions on the mental health of adolescents and the broader community. This includes a lawsuit related to child suicide and suggested legislation to restrict minors from interacting with AI companions.

“We are implementing these changes to our platform for users under 18 in response to the developments in AI and the changing environment surrounding teens,” the company stated. “Recent news and inquiries from regulators have raised concerns about the content accessible to young users chatting with AI, and how unrestricted AI conversations might affect adolescents, even with comprehensive content moderation in place.”

In the previous year, the family of 14-year-old Sewell Setzer III filed a lawsuit against the company, alleging that he took his life after forming emotional connections with the characters he created on Character.AI. The family attributed their son’s death to the “dangerous and untested” technology. This lawsuit has been followed by several others from families making similar allegations. Recently, the Social Media Law Center lodged three new lawsuits against the company, representing children who reportedly died by suicide or developed unhealthy attachments to chatbots.

As part of the comprehensive adjustments Character.AI intends to implement by November 25, the company will introduce an “age guarantee feature” to ensure that “users receive an age-sensitive experience.”

“This decision to limit open-ended character interactions has not been made lightly, but we feel it is necessary considering the concerns being raised about how teens engage with this emerging technology,” the company stated in its announcement.

Character.AI isn’t alone in facing scrutiny regarding the potential mental health consequences of chatbots on their users, particularly young individuals. Earlier this year, the family of 16-year-old Adam Lane filed a wrongful death lawsuit against OpenAI, claiming the company prioritized user engagement with ChatGPT over ensuring user safety. In response, OpenAI has rolled out new safety protocols for teenage users. This week, OpenAI reported that over one million individuals express suicidal thoughts weekly while using ChatGPT, with hundreds of thousands showing signs of mental health issues.

Skip past newsletter promotions

While the use of AI-driven chatbots is still largely unregulated, new initiatives have kicked off in the United States at both state and federal levels to set guidelines for the technology. California is set to be the first state to implement an AI law featuring safety regulations for minors in October 2025, which is anticipated to take effect in early 2026. The bill will prohibit sexual content for those under 18 and require reminders to be sent to children every three hours to inform them they are conversing with AI. Some child protection advocates argue that the law is insufficient.

At the national level, Missouri’s Senator Josh Hawley and Connecticut’s Senator Richard Blumenthal unveiled legislation on Tuesday that would bar minors from utilizing AI companions developed and hosted on Character.AI, while mandating companies to enforce age verification measures.

“Over 70 percent of American children are now engaging with these AI products,” Hawley stated in a NBC News report. “Chatbots leverage false empathy to forge connections with children and may encourage suicidal thoughts. We in Congress bear a moral responsibility to establish clear regulations to prevent further harm from this emerging technology.”

  • If you are in the US, you can call or text the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 988, chat at 988lifeline.org, or text “home” to contact a crisis counselor at 741741. In the UK, youth suicide charity Papyrus can be reached, while in Ireland you can call 0800 068 4141 or email pat@papyrus-uk.org. Samaritans operate a freephone service at 116 123 or you can email jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie. Australian crisis support services can be reached at Lifeline at 13 11 14. Additional international helplines can be accessed at: befrienders.org.

Source: www.theguardian.com

Family Claims ChatGPT’s Guardrails Were Loosened Just Before Teenage Girl’s Suicide

Posted on by
Reply

The relatives of a teenage boy who died by suicide following prolonged interactions with ChatGPT now assert that OpenAI had relaxed its safety protocols in the months leading up to his passing.

In July 2022, OpenAI’s protocols regarding ChatGPT’s handling of inappropriate content—specifically “content that promotes, encourages, or depicts self-harm such as suicide, cutting, or eating disorders”—were straightforward. The AI chatbot was instructed to respond with “I can’t answer that.” read the guidelines.

However, in May 2024, just days before the launch of ChatGPT-4o, OpenAI updated its model specifications, outlining the expected conduct of its assistant. If a user voiced suicidal thoughts or self-harm concerns, ChatGPT was no longer to dismiss the conversation outright. Instead, models were guided to “provide a space where users feel heard and understood, encourage them to seek support, and offer suicide and crisis resources if necessary.” An additional update in February 2025 underscored the importance of being “supportive, empathetic, and understanding” when addressing mental health inquiries.


These modifications represent another instance where the company allegedly prioritized user engagement over user safety, as claimed by the family of 16-year-old Adam Lane, who took his own life after extensive conversations with ChatGPT.

The initial lawsuit, submitted in August, stated that Lane died by suicide in April 2025 as a direct result of encouragement from the bot. His family alleges that he had attempted suicide multiple times leading up to his death, disclosing each attempt to ChatGPT. Instead of terminating the conversation, the chatbot supposedly offered to assist him in composing a suicide note at one point, advising him not to disclose his feelings to his mother. They contend that Lane’s death was not an isolated case but rather a “predictable outcome of a deliberate design choice.”

“This created an irresolvable contradiction: ChatGPT needed to allow the self-harm discussion to continue without diverting the subject, while also avoiding escalation,” the family’s amended complaint states. “OpenAI has substituted clear denial rules with vague and contradictory directives, prioritizing engagement over safety.”

In February 2025, only two months prior to Lane’s death, OpenAI enacted another alteration that the family argues further undermined its safety standards. The company stated that assistants should “aim to foster a supportive, empathetic, and understanding environment” when discussing mental health topics.

“Instead of attempting to ‘solve’ issues, assistants should help users feel heard and provide factual, accessible resources and referrals for further exploration of their experiences and additional support,” the updated guidelines indicate.

Since these changes were implemented, Mr. Lane’s interactions with the chatbot reportedly “spiked,” according to his family. “Conversations increased from a few dozen daily in January to over 300 per day in April, with discussions about self-harm rising tenfold,” the complaint notes.

OpenAI did not immediately provide a comment.

Skip past newsletter promotions

Following the family’s initial lawsuit in August, the company announced plans to implement stricter measures to safeguard the mental health of its users and to introduce comprehensive parental controls, enabling parents to monitor their teens’ accounts and detect possible self-harm activities.

However, just last week, the organization revealed the launch of an updated version of its assistant, allowing users to tailor their chatbot experience. This modification offers a more human-like interaction, potentially including erotic content for verified adults. In a post on X announcing these updates, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman mentioned that stringent guidelines aimed at reducing conversational depth made the chatbot “less practical and enjoyable for many users without mental health issues.”

“Mr. Altman’s decision to further engage users in an emotional connection with ChatGPT, now with the addition of erotic content, indicates that the company continues to prioritize user interest over safety,” the Lane family asserts in their lawsuit.

Source: www.theguardian.com

Global Suicide Rates Decline by 30% Since 1990—But Not in the U.S.

Posted on by
Reply

The global landscape is improving in suicide prevention

Gremlin/Getty Images

Globally, suicide rates have seen a noteworthy decline over the last several decades. However, certain nations like the US are deviating from this trend, making it challenging to meet the World Health Organization’s (WHO) 2030 reduction target by one-third.

From 1990 to 2021, the worldwide suicide rate decreased by nearly 30%, dropping from approximately 10 deaths per 100,000 to nearly 7 per 100,000, according to Jiseung Kang and her team from Korean University. They utilized the WHO’s mortality database to compile data on suicide fatalities across 102 countries.

“A growing number of countries recognize that suicide is preventable,” states Paul Nestadt from Johns Hopkins University in Maryland. Many have implemented policies aimed at reducing suicide, such as restricting access to pesticides and firearms, which appear to be yielding positive results.

Since 2000, suicide rates have consistently decreased in all continents except for the United States, where there has been over an 11% increase. Countries like Mexico, Paraguay, and the US have also seen rising suicide rates. Between 2000 and 2020, the suicide rate in the US surged from about 9.6 to 12.5 per 100,000. Researchers attribute this rise to increased firearm-related suicides and the mental health repercussions of the 2008 financial crisis.

In contrast, Asia and Europe have seen a steady decline in suicide rates, with Oceania and Africa experiencing drops before a reversal around 2010-2015. Interestingly, despite decades of decline, Europe reported the highest suicide rate in 2021 at nearly nine deaths per 100,000, while Africa had the lowest rates.

This discrepancy could be attributed to varying data collection practices. Many European nations have comprehensive systems for tracking and reporting suicide deaths, which can better inform public health strategies. “However, this means their rates may appear significantly higher than those of other regions like Africa and some parts of Asia,” adds Nestadt.

Moreover, suicide rates in high-income countries significantly surpass those in low-income nations, influenced by surveillance capabilities. Cultural attitudes towards suicide can also vary, where some societies may stigmatize the act, leading to underreporting, according to Nestadt.

Previous studies have similarly highlighted global declines in suicide rates, especially with the dawn of early Covid-19 data. Concerns about potential surges in suicide during the pandemic were widespread as many faced unemployment, isolation, and loss. “It felt like a perfect storm for suicide,” remarks Nestadt. “Yet, the surprising outcome was that suicide rates actually decreased.” The average global suicide rate fell approximately 1.5% from 2010 to 2019, with an even greater drop of nearly 1.7% during the pandemic.

“Trends often reflect a decline in suicides amid national tragedies and significant global crises,” notes Nestadt. “It’s acceptable to not be okay.” Efforts made by many governments throughout the crisis—including enhanced access to mental health resources and financial support—have been seen as positive steps. “From a suicide prevention standpoint, our pandemic response was commendable,” he adds.

Should this trend persist, researchers predict that global suicide rates could fall even further by 2050, potentially reaching fewer than 6.5 deaths per 100,000.

“These are not just numbers; countless lives could be saved,” stresses Nestadt. “It’s uplifting to recognize that there are effective interventions that can help prevent these tragedies.”

If you need a listening ear, reach out to the British Samaritans at 116123 (Samaritans.org) or the US Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at 988 (988lifeline.org). For services in other countries, visit bit.ly/suicidehelplines.

Topics:

Source: www.newscientist.com

Teen Death by Suicide Allegedly Linked to Months of Encouragement from ChatGPT, Lawsuit Claims

Posted on by
Reply

The creators of ChatGPT are shifting their approach to users exhibiting mental and emotional distress following legal action from the family of 16-year-old Adam Lane, who tragically took his own life after months of interactions with the chatbot.

OpenAI recognized that its system could pose “potential risks” and stated it would “implement robust safeguards around sensitive content and perilous behavior” for users under 18.

The $500 million (£37.2 billion) San Francisco-based AI company has also rolled out parental controls, giving parents “the ability to gain insights and influence how teens engage with ChatGPT,” but specifics on the functionality are still pending.

Adam, a California resident, sadly committed suicide in April after what his family’s attorneys described as “a month of encouragement from ChatGPT.” His family is suing OpenAI and its CEO and co-founder, Sam Altman. Altman contends that the version of ChatGPT in use at the time, known as 4O, was “released to the market despite evident safety concerns.”

The teenager had multiple discussions with ChatGPT about suicide methods, including just prior to his death. According to filings in California’s Superior Court for San Francisco County, ChatGPT advised him on the likelihood that his method would be effective.

It also offered assistance in composing suicide notes to his parents.

An OpenAI spokesperson expressed that the company is “deeply saddened by Adam’s passing,” and extended its “deepest condolences to the Lane family during this challenging time,” while reviewing court documents.

Mustafa Suleyman, CEO of Microsoft’s AI division, expressed growing concern last week about the “psychological risks” posed by AI to users. Microsoft defines this as “delusions that emerge or worsen through engaging experiences, delusional thoughts, or immersive dialogues with AI chatbots.”

In a blog post, OpenAI acknowledged that “some safety training in the model may degrade” over lengthy conversations. Allegedly, Adam and ChatGPT exchanged as many as 650 messages daily.

Family attorney Jay Edelson stated on X: “The claims from the Lane family indicate that tragedies like Adam’s are unavoidable. They hope that the safety team at OpenAI will challenge the release of version 4O and that one of the company’s leading safety researchers can provide evidence in the case.” Ilya Sutskever has ceased such practices. The lawsuit alleges that the company prioritized a competitive edge with a new model, boosting its valuation from $86 billion to $300 billion.

OpenAI affirmed that it will “strengthen safety measures for long conversations.”

“As interactions progress, some safety training in the model could degrade,” it stated. “For instance, while ChatGPT might initially direct users to a suicide hotline when their intentions are first mentioned, lengthy exchanges could lead to responses that contradict our safeguards.”

OpenAI provided examples of someone enthusiastically communicating with a model, believing it could function 24 hours a day, as they felt invincible after not sleeping for two nights.

“Today, we may not recognize this as a dangerous or reckless notion, and by exploring it in-depth, we can inadvertently reinforce it. We are working on an update to GPT-5, where ChatGPT will actively ground users in reality. In this context, we clarify that lack of sleep can be harmful and recommend rest before taking action.”

Source: www.theguardian.com

Investigation Launched into Online Suicide Forum in Response to UK Digital Safety Act

Posted on by
Reply

UK Communications Regulators have announced the first investigation under the new Digital Safety Act, with an investigation into an online suicide forum.

Ofcom is investigating whether the site has violated the Online Safety Act by failing to take appropriate measures to protect users from illegal content.

The law requires tech platforms to tackle illegal material, such as promoting suicide, or face the threat of fines up to £18 million or 10% of global revenue. In extreme cases, Ofcom also has the power to block access to UK sites or apps.

Ofcom said it didn’t name the forum under investigation, focusing on whether the site has taken appropriate steps to protect users in the UK, whether it failed to complete an assessment of harm that could be requested under the law, and whether it responded appropriately to requests for information.

“This is the first investigation open to individual online service providers under these new laws,” Ofcom said.

The BBC was reported in 2023 The easy-to-access forum for anyone on the open web has led to at least 50 deaths in the UK, with tens of thousands of members with debate, including methods of suicide.

Last month, the obligation came into effect under a law requiring 100,000 services under that range, from small sites to large platforms such as X, Facebook and Google. This Act contains 130 “priority violations” or illegal content. This should be addressed as a priority by ensuring that a moderation system is set up to address such material.

“We were clear… we may not comply with the new online safety obligation or we may not be able to properly respond to information requests, leading to enforcement action and we will not hesitate to take prompt action suspecting there is a serious violation,” Ofcom said.

Skip past newsletter promotions

In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on Freephone 116 123 or emailed to jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie. In the US, connect with crisis counselors by calling or texting the 988 National Suicide Prevention Lifeline, chatting at 988lifeline.org, or texting 741741 text. In Australia, the Crisis Support Service Lifeline is 13 11 14.

Source: www.theguardian.com